• News
    • VRM Intel News
    • Latest News
    • Sponsor News
  • COVID-19
  • Marketing
  • Tech
  • OTAs
  • Customer Service
  • Regulations
  • Business
  • Housekeeping
  • Subscribe
  • More
    • Calendar of Events
    • VRM Intel Live!
    • Reports Login
    • VRM Intel Magazine
    • Advertise
    • Authors
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
VRM Intel
  • News
    • Arizonans for Responsible Tourism Pregame Prep Campaign
      Arizonans for Responsible Tourism Hosts Super Bowl Preparedness Campaign for Vacation Rental Operators
    • vacation-rentals-housing-vrm-intel
      Carrots and sticks: Vacation rentals and the creation of affordable, workforce housing
    • Woman dropping off a ballot
      2022 Election Results of Vacation Rental Ballot Measures
    • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    • How to Increase Your Occupancy in a Competitive Market through Monthly Rentals
    • VRM Intel News
    • Latest News
    • Sponsor News
  • COVID-19
    • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    • 2022 Vacation Rental acquisitions from AvantStay, VTrips, Vacasa, Meredith, and more
      Who Sold? Here’s What We Know: 2022 Vacation Rental Management Acquisitions
    • 2021/2022 Ski Destinations Showing Big Performance Gains in ADR and RevPAR for Vacation Homes and Condos
    • “It’s like a short-term rental regulation pandemic.” 2022 Spring Vacation Rental Regulatory Trends + Fall Outlook
    • HR 2022: Attracting Today’s New Workforce after the Resignation Tsunami and the Great Renegotiation
  • Marketing
    • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    • How to Increase Your Occupancy in a Competitive Market through Monthly Rentals
    • board meeting in presentation room
      Tourism Boards and DMOs Offer Seat at the Table for Vacation Rentals
    • Geotargeting & SEM: A How-To Guide on Spending Less & Getting More
    • All About the Data: Predictive Indicators with Jason Sprenkle
  • Tech
    • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    • Geotargeting & SEM: A How-To Guide on Spending Less & Getting More
    • All About the Data: Predictive Indicators with Jason Sprenkle
    • PriceLabs Announces $30 Million Investment from Summit Partners
    • Ximplifi Adds Owner Portal to Automation Suite for Short Term Rental Accounting
  • OTAs
    • How to Increase Your Occupancy in a Competitive Market through Monthly Rentals
    • Blue Star Acquires Majority Stake in TravelNet Solutions
    • Vacation Rental Data and Revenue Management Conference, DARM 2022, Nashville
      Sessions Details for Upcoming Vacation Rental Data and Revenue Management (DARM) Conference: Livestream/Video Tickets Available
    • Vacasa (VCSA) Stock Falls as Lock-up Period Expires
    • 4 Ways to Stand Out in a Crowded Market: Get Your Brand & Listings in Front of Potential Guests
  • Customer Service
    • Why Not A Hotel? A Guest and Homeowner’s Perspective: There’s No Place Like Home … Or Is There?
    • Leading Proptech Company Guesty Appoints David Aber as CFO
    • Meredith Hospitality Brands Inc. Expands to Mt Hood with Acquisition of Mt Hood Vacation Rentals
    • View of Waikiki from Diamond Head Park, Honolulu, Hawaii
      Honolulu City Council Bans Stays Under 90 Days Across Oahu
    • Are you a Visionary without an Integrator at Your Vacation Rental Management Company?
  • Regulations
    • vacation-rentals-housing-vrm-intel
      Carrots and sticks: Vacation rentals and the creation of affordable, workforce housing
    • Woman dropping off a ballot
      2022 Election Results of Vacation Rental Ballot Measures
    • voters at a polling center voting
      Dozens of Vacation Rental Ballot Measures Heading to Voters this November
    • board meeting in presentation room
      Tourism Boards and DMOs Offer Seat at the Table for Vacation Rentals
    • Arizona state flag outside the legislature buildings at the state capitol
      Arizona Legislature Passes Measure to Restore Some Power to Cities
  • Business
    • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    • Geotargeting & SEM: A How-To Guide on Spending Less & Getting More
    • All About the Data: Predictive Indicators with Jason Sprenkle
    • PriceLabs Announces $30 Million Investment from Summit Partners
    • Ximplifi Adds Owner Portal to Automation Suite for Short Term Rental Accounting
  • Housekeeping
    • Why Not A Hotel? A Guest and Homeowner’s Perspective: There’s No Place Like Home … Or Is There?
    • Analysis: “Reinventing” Vacation Rental Management by Alex Nigg
    • HR 2022: Attracting Today’s New Workforce after the Resignation Tsunami and the Great Renegotiation
    • Safety First: Evaluating and Addressing Safety Risks at Your Vacation Rentals
    • The Importance of the Guest Experience within Vacation Rental Operations: From the Back of the House to the Front
  • Subscribe
  • More
    • Calendar of Events
    • VRM Intel Live!
    • Reports Login
    • VRM Intel Magazine
    • Advertise
    • Authors
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • RSS

Customer Service for Vacation Rental Professionals

Travel insurance: VRMs told “opt-out” not an option

Travel insurance: VRMs told “opt-out” not an option
mm
VRM Intel Staff
August 16, 2014

Commissions from selling travel insurance products provide a significant source of ancillary revenue for vacation rental managers.

Opt out options for travel insuranceOver the last decade, travel insurance representatives taught the vacation rental marketplace that they could make more money by having guests opt-out of travel insurance in the online booking process rather than opt in, leading to a 40 percent  increase in insurance sales.

As a result, professional vacation rental management companies moved to an opt-out model on their booking pages. In this model, there is typically a check box next to the travel insurance line item which is pre-checked. Guests can un-check the box to decline the insurance. Vacation rental managers were able to increase revenue from travel insurance by 30-40 percent by switching to the opt-out model.

However, CSA Travel Insurance, one of the leading travel insurance providers in the vacation rental industry, recently notified clients -including HomeAway and Wyndham Vacation Rentals -they would no longer be allowed to use an opt-out model on their websites.

CSA’s decision has precipitated a robust discussion about why the change is being made, if the deadline to implement the change makes sense, and if this is an inevitable industry standard.

 

Total buy-in of opt-out model

Switching to the opt-out model proved to be a win-win situation in the vacation rental industry. In the example below, a property manager with 8,000 annual reservations and an average stay value of $2,000 could add over $112k to their bottom line simply by pre-checking the travel insurance box.

Opt-in Opt-out
Average Stay Value $2,000 $2,000
Number of Reservations 8,000 8,000
Typical Travel Insurance Fee: 7% 7%
Percentage of stays which include travel insurance
25%
35%
Commission from travel insurance sale -35% $280,000 $392,000

 

In addition, travel insurance provides enormous protection for the homeowner, the guest and the vacation rental company.

This is especially beneficial for hurricane-prone destinations like North Carolina where the North Carolina Real Estate Commission legislated that in a hurricane event, guests are not entitled to a refund if, “prior to the tenant taking possession of the property, the tenant refused insurance offered by the landlord or real estate broker that would have compensated the tenant for losses or damages resulting from loss of use of the property due to a mandatory evacuation order.” For North Carolina property managers, the best way to comply with rental regulations is through an opt-out model.

 

Why it is a problem

CSA’s notification letter to clients in July 2014 states:

“the purchase of our insurance plans must include an affirmative selection made by the guest, and these insurance plans should not be presented in an ‘opt-out’ or mandatory fashion.”

Since CSA was a proponent of opt-out offerings, what triggered the change in direction?

In 2012, as a result of complaints about Travelocity’s hidden fees, insurance provider TravelGuard and underwriter National Union Fire Insurance (NUFIC) came under review.

Minnesota

The Minnesota Department of Commerce alleged in 2012 that TravelGuard had violated state law by automatically enrolling consumers in travel insurance without their express consent when they booked on Travelocity.com.

Unless they specifically opted out of the insurance, customers were buying policies that cost $25 to $45 per traveler, according to the state. The companies agreed to issue nearly $2.5 million in refunds and pay a $250,000 civil penalty.

Missouri

Last year the Missouri Department of Insurance announced that Missouri consumers who purchased travel insurance policies offered on Travelocity websites would be entitled to a refund of nearly $2 million.

The department alleged NUFIC violated state law by requiring consumers to affirmatively “opt-out” of buying travel insurance policies. The settlement says NUFIC will refund $2 million to Missourians who purchased travel insurance policies from the company through Travelocity and other websites powered by Travelocity from June 1, 2009 to January 24, 2012. NUFIC sold nearly 70,000 policies of its Travel Guard Protection Plan to Missourians during that time period.

“Missourians who may have been misled into purchasing unwanted travel insurance policies will be entitled to refunds,” said John M. Huff, director of the Missouri Department of Insurance. “Protecting consumer rights is essential and holding companies accountable for questionable business practices will remain at the forefront of our department’s mission.

Department of Transportation

The Transportation Department’s full-fare advertising regulations for airfares went into effect in 2012. They include a rule that prohibits opt-out provisions in ads, further closing a loophole that had “cost consumers millions and generated thousands of complaints.”

 

Since each state has its own Department of Insurance, it is up to each state how they regulate this. Minnesota, Washington and Missouri have increased regulation and have imposed fines on companies using pre-checked boxes, but it is not known if other states are reviewing opt-out booking models.

After assessing the Travelocity/Travel Guard fallout, CSA underwriter Italian-based Generali has made the interpretive decision that the risk of being reviewed and fined is greater than the reward of higher travel insurance sales.

 

To opt-in or opt-out

As a result of the change, an unnamed source, recently ended his contract with CSA and chose a different travel insurance provider. “From what we understand, this decision is not based on any pending regulations, changing industry standards or threat of fines. It is is just an arbitrary decision by CSA’s underwriter. We are a laid-back, loyal company, and we don’t like to rock the boat. But we don’t like it done to us either.”

CSA underwriter Generali believes eliminating pre-checked boxes for travel insurance is part of instituting best practices going forward in the vacation rental industry, and that the best way to protect their company and their clients’ interests is to be proactive in implementing opt-in standards.

Software companies who make a percentage of vacation rental travel insurance sales from their partnership with CSA are making changes in their system to eliminate the automatic calculation of travel insurance. For web companies, the change means the discontinued use of pre-checked boxes for adding travel insurance for CSA clients, but there are different ways to display the option, including the use of un-checked boxes and inclusive subtotals.

However, the example below still does not include an “affirmative selection made by the guest.”

Opt out travel insurance for vacation rentals

(VRM Intel is searching for an example of an opt-in model which is in compliance.) 

 

After news of TravelGuard’s troubles, along with this recent move by CSA, it appears that the opt-out model is being examined, but the elimination of an opt-out model is not currently mandatory.

It will be a difficult decision for CSA customers who wish to continue using pre-checked boxes to either change providers or comply with new underwriter policies.

 

Additional Info:

  • HomeAway and Wyndham are continuing their relationship with CSA and complying with policies.
  • LiveRez is making changes to comply with the new format.
  • Airbnb does not offer travel insurance on its website.
  • TripAdvisor’s FlipKey offers insurance in a process which is separate from the booking process.
  • Priceline has a check yes or no format (guest must check one or the other) with a second chance opt it.

 

By Amy Hinote

Related Items
Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Customer Service for Vacation Rental Professionals
August 16, 2014
mm
VRM Intel Staff

Related Items

More in Customer Service for Vacation Rental Professionals

Why Not A Hotel? A Guest and Homeowner’s Perspective: There’s No Place Like Home … Or Is There?

Ren HinoteJuly 4, 2022
Read More

Leading Proptech Company Guesty Appoints David Aber as CFO

VRM Intel StaffJune 21, 2022
Read More

Meredith Hospitality Brands Inc. Expands to Mt Hood with Acquisition of Mt Hood Vacation Rentals

VRM Intel StaffJune 21, 2022
Read More
View of Waikiki from Diamond Head Park, Honolulu, Hawaii

Honolulu City Council Bans Stays Under 90 Days Across Oahu

Alexa NotaApril 19, 2022
Read More

Are you a Visionary without an Integrator at Your Vacation Rental Management Company?

Steve TroverMarch 24, 2022
Read More

YOUR Memory Factory: Creating Lifetime Memories for Guests with those They Cherish Most

Doug KennedyOctober 16, 2021
Read More
Scroll for more
Tap

Sponsor News

  • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    BusinessOctober 18, 2022
  • How to Increase Your Occupancy in a Competitive Market through Monthly Rentals
    Industry News for Vacation Rental ManagersSeptember 16, 2022
  • PriceLabs Announces $30 Million Investment from Summit Partners
    BusinessAugust 5, 2022
  • Ximplifi Adds Owner Portal to Automation Suite for Short Term Rental Accounting
    BusinessAugust 4, 2022
VRM Intel
Calendar of Events
Videos & Whitepapers
VRMintel Magazine
Subscribe
Advertise
About Us
Authors
Contact Us

Recent News

  • Arizonans for Responsible Tourism Pregame Prep Campaign
    Arizonans for Responsible Tourism Hosts Super Bowl Preparedness Campaign for Vacation Rental Operators
    Industry News for Vacation Rental ManagersJanuary 18, 2023
  • vacation-rentals-housing-vrm-intel
    Carrots and sticks: Vacation rentals and the creation of affordable, workforce housing
    Industry News for Vacation Rental ManagersDecember 6, 2022
  • Woman dropping off a ballot
    2022 Election Results of Vacation Rental Ballot Measures
    Industry News for Vacation Rental ManagersNovember 11, 2022
  • Recession-Proofing Your Vacation Rental Business
    BusinessOctober 18, 2022

View Current Issue

VRMintel Copyright © 2016-17 | Click HERE to Subscribe | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Copyright | Jobs | Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn

Milne resigns from Wyndham, Marriott exec named President Vacation Rentals North America
Priceline.com Chief Marketing Officer Brett Keller to Give Keynote Speech at the 2014 LiveRez Partner Conference

xxx videos

  • mamadas
  • redwap
  • free porn
  • porno gratis